Tuesday, 2 February 2010

Institutional Investors Lose Money Just Like Individual Investors

Absence of Value: An Analysis of Investment Allocation Decisions by Institutional Plan Sponsors by Scott D. Stewart, John J. Neumann, Christopher R. Knittel and Jeffrey Heisler in the Nov/Dec 2009 issue of the Financial Analysts Journal tells us that pension plans, endowments, foundations and other large pools of assets ($10 trillion in 2006) make exactly the same mistakes and get the same poor results as individual investors. "Much like individual investors, who seem to switch mutual funds at the wrong time, institutional investors do not appear to create value from their investment decisions." In fact, the study shows they lost money and lots of it.

This is despite the fact that "Pension plans, endowments and foundations are typically staffed with professionals with years of experience and advanced degrees."

Index investing with a fixed asset allocation seems more sensible every time a new study comes out.

I am left with this question - if individual investors lose money on average over extended periods and the pros do too, who the heck IS making money?

PS - acknowledgement to Index Funds Advisors whose excellent newsletter included the link to the study.

PPS just realized that I've been doing this blog for three complete years now. It is a sort of full circle in that my second post on Feb.1, 2007 was about a paper on the same subject as today's. The 7 Deadly Sins of Investors seems to apply as much to institutional investors as individuals.

Sunday, 31 January 2010

New Data on TFSA vs RRSP and Canada's Rube Goldberg Tax System

Cartoonist Rube Goldberg was famous for his drawings of incredibly complex, convoluted machines. That's Canada's income tax system. A new paper from the CD Howe Institute Saver’s Choice: Comparing the Marginal Effective Tax Burdens on RRSPs and TFSAs (kudos to Don Cayo of the Vancouver Sun on whose blog I found the link) reveals the gory detail of the complexity created by the interaction of all the start and stop levels of tax credits, tax brackets, tax surcharges, rebates and clawbacks. The table they show for an Ontario taxpayer has no less than 33 income levels at which tax rates either go up or down. Contrary to popular belief, the tax you pay on your next dollar of income, the marginal rate, does NOT go up constantly and smoothly. It bounces up and down by more than 100% for very small rises in income. These tax items are not special rules for individuals in unique circumstances, it is what everyone faces.

What's more, and what is important for the average person trying to decide whether to put savings into a TFSA or an RRSP, as a result the better choice flip-flops back and forth between TFSA and RRSP. The answer varies by: Province, by income in retirement compared to during working life (the replacement rate) and by working life income level.

CD Howe's Findings
  • $20-30,000 or so working income, TFSA always is better and by a massive amount, the GIS clawback being the primary cause as TFSA withdrawals are not included as income for the calculation while RRSP withdrawals are included.
  • $35-45,000 or so working income, RRSP is better but not by nearly as much as the TFSA advantage in the bullet above
  • the boundary between TFSA and RRSP shifts higher as retirement income replacement is lower e.g. in Ontario, at 80% retirement replacement, the TFSA is better up to around $30,000 working income but at 60% replacement, the TFSA is better up to about $39,000
  • TFSA is better across most of the working life income spectrum for Alberta and Quebec and most income replacement levels
  • most surprising, TFSA is everywhere best for the highest income earners of $110,000+ even when their income replacement is only 60% - one would have thought they would end up in a much lower tax bracket and thus conform to the general principle that RRSP is best when your tax rate is less in retirement.
  • above low income levels, the advantage for TFSA or RRSP is not enormous (less than 10%+/- in marginal tax rate), except for huge spikes up or down in Ontario
  • a change of only a few thousand dollars in working income can shift the balance, sometimes drastically, from TFSA to RRSP or vice versa, especially in the band $35,000 up to about $80,000 in Ontario (which leads me to conclude that Ontario residents face the most uncertain, difficult and chaotic tax system as far as TFSA vs RRSP planning goes)
Ontario residents in the income range from $35,000 to about $90,000 probably need most to hedge their bets about where their retirement tax rate will end up and to contribute to both their TFSA and RRSP. At least both benefit from the powerful advantage of tax-protected compounded growth while funds are in the plan.

Unfortunately, CD Howe only looked at the numbers for Ontario, Alberta and Quebec, so taxpayers in other Provinces must be wondering where they stand. Don Cayo got preliminary data from CD Howe about BC, which he says is similar to Ontario.

The Federal government could do us a favour by expanding TFSA contribution room to make it equal to the RRSP, or make it a combined total that people can divide between the two as they choose.

Friday, 29 January 2010

McKinsey deflates another bubble

Those who think that now that the recession is over, everything is fine and happy days are here again might think a second thought after reading strategic consulting company McKinsey's The Looming Deleveraging Challenge (free registration required for access to the report). We Canadians might be especially over-confident given the minimal harm our banks suffered during the 2008 crisis.

Despite having the lowest total of public and private debt amongst the 14 countries studied, Canada still likely faces deleveraging in the household sector according to McKinsey. The BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, China) countries are all much less constrained by debt. The USA, Spain and the UK are more likely to have deleveraging in more sectors than Canada.

McKinsey says deleveraging countries face prolonged belt tightening and lower economic growth for two to three years. Given Canada's strong economic ties to the USA and their even worse state, I'd guess we are in that boat. Ssssssss is the sound of the slow leak in the hope bubble.

The good news is that GDP growth, based on past examples McKinsey studied, likely resumes strongly after that. It will again be time to take a deep breath and start inflating a new bubble.

Live Online Investing Q&A with No Hype Author Gail Bebee

Gail Bebee, author of the investing book No Hype - The Straight Goods on Investing Your Money will answer investing questions online today January 29th from noon to 1pm on the Globe Investor website. It's a good book so she should provide sensible unbiased answers. Click here.

Thursday, 28 January 2010

Bank Shenanigans: Post-Dated and Stopped Cheques

Did you know that post-dated cheques and stopped cheques can cause you considerable grief?

Yesterday, I discovered that my (current) bank, the Bank of Montreal, had processed and withdrawn funds from my account despite the fact that the cheque I had written was post-dated for about a week later. When I called the customer service line expecting some sort of redress for what I perceived to be BMO's negligence, I was told that they would do nothing, that they had done nothing wrong or negligent in any way, since the bank is under no obligation to prevent funds from being withdrawn early. If sufficient funds are in the account, then it is paid no problem. What if sufficient funds are not in the account I asked, would there not be NSF charges incurred? The answer unfortunately seems to be yes, I would be on the hook. If a had a problem I should speak to the cheque recipient who had presented the cheque early. Conclusion: the date you write has no significance and is no protection. Post-dated cheques are not a reliable or trustworthy hassle-free method of managing bank account cash inflows and outflows.

A Google search uncovered this Canadian Payments Association FAQ on Cheques that confirms the optional, non-obligatory, one might say at the convenience of the banks, nature of the usual practice to tell the recipient that it is only to be presented on the due date. Note the red highlighted weasel words should and may.

Relevant quote:
" Under CPA Rules, a post-dated cheque is not eligible for clearing and therefore should not be deposited before the due date. However, given the large volume of cheques and the degree of automated processing, some post-dated items may inadvertently slip through. Under Rule A4, Section 6(b), a payment item may be returned through the clearing by a CPA member financial institution for the reason "post-dated" up to and including the day prior to the due date."

Even granting there might be some unstated necessity to exempt the banks from the legal responsibility for their incompetence in providing the service a post-dated cheque is intended to do, the symptomatic attitude "if we at the bank screw up, it's you the customer's problem to fix" is, shall we put it politely, annoying. Unfortunately, I see no solution but to either harass the bank if material losses like NSF charges occur, or not to write post-dated cheques at all.

Paying electronically is just as fraught with uncertainty and bank freedom. You must pay a couple of days in advance since the banks do not guarantee even then that the payment will occur instantaneously on the due date - BMO's blurb from the Agreements for Everyday Banking states its huge leeway in the section on automated services: this
"However, we may require up to five banking days:
- to process any deposit, including any transfer between Accounts;

- to act on bill payment instructions."
and on the website, BMO gives itself this liberty:
"For future-dated bill payments, please ensure you have sufficient funds in the account you have selected at least 1 business day prior to the payment date." i.e. they may withdraw the payment a day early as I have seen happen. Not very impressive in the computer age I'd say.

The other problem I came across while looking for information on the above. When you put a stop payment on a cheque, you are still exposed to it being cashed and having to pay anyway. The simple version explanation of how this can happen is in Before you write a cheque, take note of this little known law that appeared in the Vancouver Sun. A more complicated nuanced explanation is Lost and Stolen Cheques, Bank Drafts and Trust Cheques: Some Modest but Partial Solutions in the March 2009 Advocate. As the title of the article states, problems can arise from cheques that are lost or stolen. The basic though not perfect solution is to a) cross all cheques, that is, draw two parallel diagonal or vertical lines across the cheque; b) add the words, "for deposit only by payee - non negotiable"; c) add the words "not payable more than X days after date". Or they suggest using a wire transfer since that puts the bank on the hook.

I wish it were possible to get protection by adding the words "not payable before date" to counter the prematurely expectorated post-dated cheque but I guess the Bills of Exchange Act that created this reality seems not to have contemplated the value of enabling people to pay with certainty only on a due date and not before.

You also have to the crossing by hand since it seems there aren't any companies in Canada offering cheques pre-printed with the crossing done. Surely the banks and cheque printing companies know the advantages. Why don't they begin offering pre-crossed cheques? In the UK, such cheques are commonly available.

Friday, 22 January 2010

The Index Finger Moves on - Shrinking TSX and Declining Index Effect

The Shrinking TSX
Another ones bites the dust. As I noted last year, the TSX Composite Index has been shrinking for years. That seems to be continuing, though at a slower pace. When Enerflex Systems Income Fund (EFX.UN) leaves the index next week as the result of a buyout (see Standard & Poors press release) the TSX Composite will be down to 210 companies, a third fewer than a mere nine years ago. One would have thought equity markets should expand over time, not shrink.

When one considers that the largest US all-company index the Wilshire 5000 Total Market Index contains about 5000 companies, it is apparent how small and thin the Canadian market is. All the more reason to diversify outside Canada in my opinion.

The Shrinking Index Effect
The index effect is the excess returns or profits from trading on a stock that is being added to a major index, such as the TSX 60, the S&P 500 or the UK's FTSE 100. The addition of a stock to an index causes its price to rise unduly as indexers (and closet indexers) rush to buy it. A neat little 2008 paper by Aye Soe and Srikant Dash from Standard and Poors called The Shrinking Index Effect showed how the opportunity to make such profits has declined considerably to the point they think "... its days as a profitable trading strategy may be numbered". They looked at five different major indices, the above three plus Japan's Nikkei 225 and Germany's DAX 30.

The paper is a good brief primer on the various indices and how they are changed. It's interesting that the FTSE 100 and DAX 30 changes are quite mechanical and predictable while those of the TSX 60 and the S&P 500 are not.

Buyers of passive index funds, which automatically buy into index changes and have to pay the higher price that follows the announcement price pop, may take heart that they are being less taken advantage of. To quote the authors: "... hedge funds and proprietary trading desks have increased their market participation in index trades to exploit this opportunity. As with any arbitrage opportunity, increase in arbitrageur activity has diminished profits." Arbitragers are not the only factor at work but the net effect is the market becoming more efficient! The chart image below taken from the study shows the big decline - the upper vs the lower line at time ED (ED means the day the entry of a stock into the index takes effect) - in available trading profits from TSX 60 changes between 1998-2003 and 2003-2008.


Of course, the efficiency process is never finished. Srikant Dash and Berlinda Liu suggest in another paper at SSRN called Capturing the Index Effect via Options, that arbitragers can continue to make large excess profits (31% on average on the S&P 500) by trading options instead of the stock itself.

Wednesday, 20 January 2010

Retirement: A Second Career, aka the Sisyphus Solution

One of the positive alternatives to living at a much reduced standard of living in retirement is to start a second career. Now that might sound a lot like not actually retiring at all, but maybe it is in the mindset.

In the CFA's The Future of Life Cycle Saving and Investing: the Retirement Phase, Anna Rappaport says people thinking of retirement "... want work to fit around their lifestyle rather than making their lifestyle fit around work." In the same report, Alicia Munnell gives us a clue why: "According to psychologists, as we age, we have a tendency to “positivize” or to divest ourselves of people and situations that we no longer enjoy. When I’ve asked retirees in the past “Why did you retire?” they gave what sounded like the most frivolous reasons: “I sat in the middle seat,” “I was on the tarmac for two hours,” “I’m just not doing this anymore,” “I’m sick of it,” or “I got a new, young boss, and I can’t stand the guy, and I’m out of here.”
The tendency to positivize also applies to the work environment. Our tolerance for putting up with things we don’t like diminishes as we age."

Along comes the solution of a second career, in which you do something you like. Novel idea! Munnell says that happens a lot with second careers: "The Urban Institute recently studied the nature of these new jobs, or second careers, held by older workers and found that, although they paid less and provided less in the way of fringe benefits, people generally liked these new jobs much better. They experienced less stress, and they were closer to their homes; the second career had a lot of positive attributes."

The big financial benefit is that every dollar earned in a second career is a dollar less required to live on from savings and investments.

Of course, there is a catch. Working, especially doing fulfilling work, is good for your health and you will probably live longer as a result. Oops, now your savings have to last even longer, so you will have to work even longer and put off entering the ideal(?) but fatal state of being a couch potato. We could borrow from Albert Camus and call this the Sisyphus Solution - endless work that makes people happy.

Some resources on second careers:

Wikinvest Wire